MathCraft vs Komodo Maths
Komodo deliberately rejects gamification — it's the "anti-game" with human teacher oversight and a martial arts belt system. MathCraft embraces gameplay as the learning mechanism. Two philosophically opposite approaches to the same problem.
At a Glance
| Feature | MathCraft | Komodo Maths |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | Free | £9.99 |
| Annual price | Free | ~£89.99 |
| Free tier | Yes — completely free | None (14-day free trial, no card required) |
| Age range | 5–14 (Y1–Y9) | 5–11 (KS1–KS2) |
| Curriculum | UK National / White Rose Maths | Arithmetic and numeracy only (geometry/shapes "under development") |
| Adaptive engine | ✓ Spaced repetition + mastery tracking | Human-teacher-set personalised plans with 15-minute timed drill sessions |
| Platforms | Web (PWA — any device) | Web, iOS, Android, Kindle |
| Offline mode | ✗ No (internet required) | ✗ No |
| AI tutoring | ✓ Merlin (Socratic, logged) | ✗ No |
| Parent dashboard | ✓ Curriculum heatmap + AI logs | "Supporters" feature lets parents and grandparents send encouragement messages that appear in the app. Progress tracking by belt level. |
| Ads / dark patterns | ✗ None | ✗ None |
What Komodo Maths Does Well
Komodo Maths has genuine strengths that are worth acknowledging:
- Unique human teacher involvement — a qualified UK maths teacher creates your child's learning plan
- Results guarantee: "If you're not seeing clear results, we'll refund your payment"
- Belt progression system with physical sticker charts mailed to families
- Clean, uncluttered design suits children with sensory processing needs
- Good dyslexia/SEN accommodations
- Built-in "go and play" message actively limits screen time
Where Komodo Maths Falls Short
No app is perfect. These are the most common complaints from parents and reviews:
- Only covers arithmetic — no geometry, measurement, data, or problem-solving
- Most expensive mainstream option at £9.99/month
- Heavy repetition bores advanced children
- Setup delay — waiting for teacher assessment before starting
- No offline mode
- Deliberately rejects gamification — co-founder stated "we weren't looking for" extended engagement
How MathCraft Is Different
Komodo is philosophically the opposite of MathCraft. Komodo deliberately minimises engagement and screen time; MathCraft maximises engagement through RPG gameplay. Komodo covers arithmetic only; MathCraft covers the full curriculum. Komodo is the most expensive option at £9.99/month; MathCraft is completely free. Komodo's human teacher element is unique, but MathCraft's AI tutor (Merlin) offers on-demand Socratic support.
MathCraft’s Approach
- Stealth learning — maths is woven into RPG quests, not bolted on top
- Companion & island — your child raises a creature and builds a world through correct answers
- AI tutor (Merlin) — Socratic hints, never gives answers, every conversation logged for parents
- Adaptive engine — spaced repetition + mastery tracking meets your child where they are
- Hard time limits — parent-set daily cap, no dark patterns, app locks when time expires
- Full parent dashboard — curriculum heatmap, AI logs, topic-by-topic mastery
The Verdict
Choose Komodo Maths if…
Families who value human teacher oversight and a deliberately screen-time-limited approach to arithmetic fluency.
Choose MathCraft if…
Your child resists anything that feels like homework and needs genuine game engagement. You want UK curriculum alignment, adaptive practice, AI tutoring, and full parent visibility — all in a game they’ll actually ask to play.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Komodo Maths worth the price?
At £9.99/month, Komodo is the most expensive mainstream maths app. You're paying for human teacher involvement — a qualified UK teacher reviews your child's assessment and creates a personalised plan. If you value that human element and want minimal screen time, it could be worth it. If you want full curriculum coverage and engagement, MathCraft offers more for less.
Does Komodo cover the full maths curriculum?
No. Komodo covers arithmetic and numeracy only — geometry, measurement, data, and problem-solving are listed as "under development." MathCraft covers the full White Rose Maths curriculum across Years 1-9, including geometry, algebra, data, and more.
Which is better for a reluctant learner?
It depends on the child. Some reluctant learners respond well to Komodo's calm, structured, low-stimulus approach — especially children with sensory processing needs. Others need the intrinsic motivation of a genuine game like MathCraft. If worksheets bore your child, MathCraft is likely the better fit. If screen time itself is the concern, Komodo's deliberate minimisation may appeal.
Does Komodo have a results guarantee?
Yes — Komodo offers a unique results guarantee: "If you use Komodo regularly and you're not seeing clear results, we'll refund your payment." MathCraft is completely free, so there's no financial risk to trying it.
Looking at more options? See our Best Alternatives to Mathletics guide.
More Comparisons
Start Practising with MathCraft
Step-by-step lessons, worked examples, and adaptive practice — all wrapped in an adventure game your child will love.
Try MathCraft Free No credit card required