MathCraft vs MyMaths
MyMaths is a school-only homework platform that parents can't buy. MathCraft is a parent-purchasable RPG game. If your child dreads MyMaths homework, MathCraft offers curriculum-aligned practice they'll actually enjoy.
At a Glance
| Feature | MathCraft | MyMaths |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | Free | N/A (school only) |
| Annual price | Free | £370+VAT (school licence) |
| Free tier | Yes — completely free | None — school-gated |
| Age range | 5–14 (Y1–Y9) | 5–18 (KS1–A Level) |
| Curriculum | UK National / White Rose Maths | Full maths + GCSE/A Level exam prep (AQA, Edexcel, White Rose) |
| Adaptive engine | ✓ Spaced repetition + mastery tracking | Teacher-assigned digital worksheets with auto-marking |
| Platforms | Web (PWA — any device) | Web only (no app) |
| Offline mode | ✗ No (internet required) | ✗ No |
| AI tutoring | ✓ Merlin (Socratic, logged) | ✗ No |
| Parent dashboard | ✓ Curriculum heatmap + AI logs | None. Parents cannot access MyMaths independently. Teachers can't even see which specific questions students got wrong. |
| Ads / dark patterns | ✗ None | ✗ None |
What MyMaths Does Well
MyMaths has genuine strengths that are worth acknowledging:
- Complete curriculum from Reception to A Level in one platform
- Aligned to all major UK exam boards (AQA, Edexcel) and White Rose Maths
- Step-by-step animated worked examples for every topic
- Saves teachers an estimated 2 hours per week on marking
- Questions auto-regenerate on retry to prevent answer-copying
Where MyMaths Falls Short
No app is perfect. These are the most common complaints from parents and reviews:
- Trustpilot rating of 1.3/5 — overwhelmingly negative student reviews
- Correct answers frequently marked wrong due to format sensitivity
- Students must redo entire question sets if they get any answer wrong
- Interface widely described as terrible
- Zero gamification, zero engagement mechanics
- No app, no offline mode, no parent dashboard
- Parents cannot purchase or access it independently
How MathCraft Is Different
MyMaths is the polar opposite of MathCraft — a digital worksheet platform with zero engagement. MyMaths relies on school compulsion; MathCraft creates genuine want-to-play motivation. MyMaths has broader exam prep coverage but delivers a miserable user experience. MathCraft is parent-purchasable and child-enjoyable.
MathCraft’s Approach
- Stealth learning — maths is woven into RPG quests, not bolted on top
- Companion & island — your child raises a creature and builds a world through correct answers
- AI tutor (Merlin) — Socratic hints, never gives answers, every conversation logged for parents
- Adaptive engine — spaced repetition + mastery tracking meets your child where they are
- Hard time limits — parent-set daily cap, no dark patterns, app locks when time expires
- Full parent dashboard — curriculum heatmap, AI logs, topic-by-topic mastery
The Verdict
Choose MyMaths if…
Schools wanting a cheap, comprehensive homework-setting platform with auto-marking. Good A Level revision content.
Choose MathCraft if…
Your child resists anything that feels like homework and needs genuine game engagement. You want UK curriculum alignment, adaptive practice, AI tutoring, and full parent visibility — all in a game they’ll actually ask to play.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can parents buy MyMaths for home use?
No. MyMaths is exclusively sold to schools — there is no parent or home subscription available. Students can only access it through school-provided logins. If you want home maths practice, MathCraft, DoodleMaths, or Mathletics are parent-purchasable alternatives.
Why do students hate MyMaths?
MyMaths has a 1.3/5 Trustpilot rating. Common complaints include correct answers being marked wrong due to format sensitivity, having to redo entire question sets for a single mistake, a terrible interface, and zero engagement features. Students have called it "depression creating" in reviews.
Is MathCraft better than MyMaths for learning?
MyMaths has broader exam prep coverage (up to A Level) and strong worked examples. But its user experience is widely criticised. MathCraft covers Year 1-9 with adaptive practice, AI tutoring, and RPG engagement that makes children want to practise. For daily home practice, MathCraft provides a significantly better experience.
Does MathCraft align to the same curriculum as MyMaths?
Both align to the UK National Curriculum and White Rose Maths. MyMaths also covers GCSE and A Level content (AQA, Edexcel). MathCraft currently covers Year 1-9 (KS1 to KS3), with content aligned to the White Rose Maths progression.
Looking at more options? See our Best Alternatives to MyMaths guide.
More Comparisons
Start Practising with MathCraft
Step-by-step lessons, worked examples, and adaptive practice — all wrapped in an adventure game your child will love.
Try MathCraft Free No credit card required